Filetype PDF | Posted on 06 Jan 2023 | 3 years ago
Authentication
digital resources
228x Filetype PDF File size 0.76 MB Source: www.childtrends.org
VOLUME 2, ISSUE 3 JULY 25, 2011
VOLUME 2, ISSUE 3 JULY 25, 2011
Early Childhood Policy Focus:
What is the
Healthy Eating Index? Healthy Eating and Physical Activity
The Healthy Eating Index (HEI) measures By David Murphey, Bonnie Mackintosh and Marci McCoy-Roth
how well a person’s diet conforms to
The importance of good nutrition and exercise is well known, and
the U.S. Department of Agriculture’s
recommended servings of the five major parents have long worried about their children’s diets and envied
food groups as well as the total their high energy levels. Like so many life style habits, patterns of
fat/saturated fat consumption, sodium, nutrition and exercise behaviors are typically established in early
and cholesterol intake. childhood. Poor diet and lack of exercise contribute to obesity, which
has been associated with higher rates of many diseases (e.g. diabetes
Revised in 2005, the HEI is comprised of 1
12 components: total fruit, whole fruit and heart disease). These diseases account for a major share of total
(not juice), total vegetables, dark green health care costs and threaten to reverse the recent gains in life-
and orange vegetables and legumes, expectancy in the United States. Though we typically think of young
total grains, whole grains, milk (all children as naturally getting lots of physical exercise, recent studies
milk/soy products), meat, poultry, fish, suggest this may not be the case. Poor nutrition and lack of exercise
eggs oils (vegetable oils and oils in fish,
nuts, and seeds), saturated fat, sodium, are jeopardizing our young children’s abilities to do well in school and
and calories from solid fats and added to stay in good health.
sugars. A number of factors affect the nutrition and exercise habits of young
children, including personal choices by parents and children, financial
constraints (such as the availability, accessibility, and cost of healthy
options), and public policies. Research on these factors offers insights
into ways to encourage the development of healthy eating and
physical fitness habits in early childhood and beyond.
WHAT YOUNG CHILDREN EAT:
HOW GOOD (OR BAD) ARE THEIR DIETS?
According to the most recent Healthy Eating Index, children (ages 2-5)
scored an average of 60 (of 100) points for healthy eating. Children’s
diets were reported as healthiest in terms of their consumption of
total fruits, total grains, and milk; they were worst in terms of dark
Recommended Food Plate green and orange vegetables and legumes, whole grains, and
Source: U.S. Department of Agriculture 2
saturated fat. These findings suggest that children need to increase
www.choosemyplate.gov/ their consumption of vitamin-rich foods, nutrient-dense foods (those
low in fat and that do not contain added sugars) and decrease their
intake of sodium, saturated fat and high calorie foods.
CHILD TRENDS: EARLY CHILDHOOD HIGHLIGHTS 1
VOLUME 2, ISSUE 3 JULY 25, 2011
Income Effects on Food Insecurity Impact of Insufficient Diets on Young Children’s
Health and Well-Being
Insufficient diets can jeopardize children’s development, threaten
Household income can significantly their readiness for school, and have lifelong effects on adult
affect children’s diets. productivity. Adequate consumption of important nutrients (notably
vitamins A, C, D, and E, and phosphorus and magnesium) is critical for
3
Children in households with incomes normal growth and development and learning. Young children who
do not get enough vitamins and nutrients may be negatively impacted
below the poverty line are six times in terms of how well and how much they can learn.4
more likely to have low food security
than their counterparts in Figure 1. Percentage of all children (0 to 17) in US living in
households with incomes at 185 Food-Insecure Households, Selected Years, 1995-2009
percent of poverty or higher; and 25 23 24
they are fourteen times more likely 19 19
to experience very low food security. 20 17 18 18 18 17 17 17
age15
rcent10
Though households with higher eP
incomes spend more money on food 5 1.3 1.5 1.3
than lower income households, this 0 0.7 0.6 0.8 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.6 0.9
represents a smaller proportion of
their income. In food-insecure 1995 1999 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009
households, families tend to spend Food Insecure Households Low Food Security Households
less on food than do families in food-
secure households5 suggesting that Source: Child Trends DataBank13
when resources are tight, families
More than 9.6 million U.S. children (ages 0-6) live in “food insecure”
may buy less food and/or less
expensive foods. households, in which consistently getting enough food to eat is a
5
struggle. Children who have been identified as “food insecure” are
reported to have higher rates of hospitalization, iron-deficiency
Children who are Hispanic, black, or anemia, and other chronic health conditions. In very young children
living with a single parent are also (3 years old), studies have associated food insecurity with higher rates
much more likely to be food- of behavioral problems. Paradoxically, child food insecurity is also
insecure than are children who are associated with a greater risk for being overweight. In part, this is
white or living in married-couple because food insecurity can result in a lower-quality diet with less
5 variety, which can contribute to being overweight. The unpredictable
families.
availability of food can also lead to overeating, especially among
6
children. In addition, there have been reports of increased
psychosocial deficits, as well as higher rates of anxiety and
depression. Food-insecure children also experience smaller gains in
math and reading achievement between kindergarten and third
grade, and (for 6-11 year olds) have a higher likelihood of repeating a
6
grade.
CHILD TRENDS: EARLY CHILDHOOD HIGHLIGHTS 2
VOLUME 2, ISSUE 3 JULY 25, 2011
When and Where Children Eat Matters
Risk Factors for Being In a recent representative sample, U.S. families reported that most
Overweight/Obese daily family meals (73 percent) are eaten at home, though experts
suggest families may over-consume poor-quality or “convenience”
7
Being overweight is widespread among pre-packaged foods, which are often high in sodium and fat. On
8
young children, a condition which is average, families reported eating out less than once a week. While
particularly prevalent among children these reports are encouraging, they may not represent the full story.
from lower-income families. An A recent USDA study showed that, on average, one-third of children’s
estimated 17 percent of all children calorie intake is “away-from-home” food. Food from fast-food and
(ages 2-19 years) are overweight, other restaurants has been associated with increased caloric intake
reflecting an alarming increase over the and lower diet quality, while consumption of sweetened beverages
33
past 20 years. (e.g., non-diet soda, fruit juice) accounts for about 35 percent of the
Specifically, about one in ten infants and 9
calories associated with “away-from-home” food.
toddlers is considered overweight Skipping meals and snacking can also result in weight gain and
th
(having a BMI at or above the 95
31 nutritional deficiencies. More than one in eight children report rarely
percentile). By age five, nearly one in or never eating breakfast, and one in four skip dinner at least some of
four (24%) is considered overweight 10
th 32 the time. Skipping meals (especially breakfast) has serious negative
(BMI at or above the 85 percentile).
Overweight infants, toddlers, and effects on learning, particularly if children are already nutritionally at
preschoolers are more likely to become risk.11 Snacking is associated with nutrient-poor calories, because the
overweight as adolescents and adults. snack foods children report eating tend to offer little in the way of
One study found that children who were vitamins, minerals, and protein, and are relatively high in sugar and
overweight as preschoolers were more fat. In a nationally representative, random sample, children reported
than five times as likely as their peers to that they frequently snack while doing other activities (e.g., while
be overweight at age 12.34
doing homework, watching television), which may contribute to a
In contrast to trends among other age- greater amount of calories consumed. About one-fourth of children
groups, the increase in overweight reported eating while watching TV, and about 25 percent of the
among the youngest children has children reported they typically snack after dinner.12
stabilized in recent years.34 These data
suggest there may be an important
window where interventions can
promote healthy eating that may have
lasting effects. See Figure 2.
CHILD TRENDS: EARLY CHILDHOOD HIGHLIGHTS 3
VOLUME 2, ISSUE 3 JULY 25, 2011
What Works? Figure 2. Percent of Overweight Children Ages 2-19
Research-Based Approaches to by Age, Selected Years 1976-2008
Promoting Eating and Physical
Activity 2007-2008
10.2
Research has shown that programs that 2003-2006
successfully promote healthy lifestyles 12.4
emphasize teaching children how to 1999-2002 Ages 12-19
incorporate exercise into their daily 10.3
routines and making physical activity 1988-1994 Ages 6-11
fun. Best results were found when Ages 2-5
programs were implemented for more 1976-1980
than 6 months.35
Programs that focus on only one aspect 0 5 10 15 20 25
(nutrition, physical activity, or weight Percentage
loss) tend to be more successful than
13
those that simultaneously focus on all Source: Child Trends DataBank
three outcome categories, suggesting Physical Activity and Screen Time:
that each outcome needs to be targeted
in a highly specified manner rather than Are young children getting enough exercise?
a “one size fits all” approach.36 The wide availability and variety of passive entertainment media
Both family- and school-based settings (television, video games, computers, etc.) may also be negatively
can be effective for impacting child affecting the level of children’s physical activity. The American
nutrition, physical activity, and weight Academy of Pediatrics (AAP) recommends that screen-media with
loss. Young children often respond to very young children (younger than 2 years) should be avoided.14 For
modeling from those around them and children ages 2 years and older, the AAP recommends watching no
behavioral prompts (e.g. telling a child 15
more than 1-2 hours of “quality programming” per day, and that
that “drinking milk will make you 16
37 children should not have televisions in their bedrooms. Despite
strong”). these recommendations, a recent Oregon study of 2-year-olds found
Since many children’s meals are that nearly one in five (20 percent) spent more than two hours of a
prepared by others, some effective typical day watching television or videos, and one in six (18 percent)
strategies include improving school had a television in their bedroom, which has been associated with
breakfast and lunch menus, to 17
incorporate more fresh fruit and increased media use. According to a stratified randomized study,
vegetables, as well as educating families each incremental hour of watching television at age two was
about ways to incorporate healthier associated with corresponding declines in school engagement, math
38 achievement, and weekend physical activity, and with increases in
eating into family routines. bullying by classmates, consumption of soft drinks and snacks, and
18
BMI at age 10.
Among young children (birth through six years old), two-thirds live in
homes where the television is on at least half of the time, and one-
third where the TV is on “always” or “most of the time.” Children in
these settings are more likely to watch TV every day and to watch for
CHILD TRENDS: EARLY CHILDHOOD HIGHLIGHTS 4
no reviews yet
Please Login to review.
