Sheet 1: Commercial MES

	
	
	
	
	
	
	
	
	
	
	
	
	
	
	
	
	
	
	
	

		
Software
		
Functionalities
		


		


		


	
	

		


		


		


	
	

		
Vendor
		
MES Tool
		
Machine task allocation
		
Detailed Scheduling 
		
Dispatching Production Units 
		
Document Control
		
Tracking and Traceability
		
Quality Management
		
Maintenance
		
Performance Analysis (KPI reporting)
		


		


		


	
	

		


		
Machine Data acquisition
		
People Productivity (labor tracking and assistance) 
		
Product (Job) Tracking 
		
Material Tracking (Inventory, WIP, consumption) 
		
Energy consumption tracking
		
OEE and Downtime tracking 
		
Process monitoring 
		
Tool tracking
		


		
Total
		
TnT
		
score
	
	

		
SAP ME
		
SAP ME
		


		
Y
		


		


		
Y
		
Y
		
Y
		
Y
		


		


		


		


		


		
Y
		
Y
		
7
		
4
		
2.15384615384615
	
	

		
SAP
		
SAP MII
		


		
Y
		


		


		
Y
		
Y
		
Y
		
Y
		


		


		


		


		


		
Y
		

		Author:
Data Requested
		Y
		
7
		
4
		
2.15384615384615
	
	

		
Schneider Electric
		
AMPLA
		


		


		


		


		


		
Y
		
Y
		
Y
		
Y
		
Y
		


		


		
Y
		


		

		Author:
1. OEE
2. Asset utilization
3. Process Quality
4. Yield
5. Energy Consumption
		Y
		
7
		
5
		
2.69230769230769
	
	

		
Siemens
		
SIMATIC IT
		


		
Y
		


		
Y
		
Y
		
Y
		
Y
		


		


		
Y
		


		


		
Y
		


		

		Author:
1. Labor Time
- Training
- Maintenance
2. Order updates
3. Cost or rework
4. Constarints on tool 
5. Yield
6. Scrap
7. Cost of quality
		Y
		
8
		
4
		
2.46153846153846
	
	

		
IBS
		
IBS:MES
		
Y
		
Y
		


		


		
Y
		


		
Y
		
Y
		


		


		


		


		
Y
		
Y
		

		Author:
1. SPC
2. Energy usage
3. Time
- Total setup time
- Runtime
- Total downtime
- Reason of downtime
4. Defect (Pass/Fail)
5. Operational cost
6. Quantity

		Y
		
8
		
3
		
1.84615384615385
	
	

		
sepasoft
		
Track & Trace 
		


		
Y
		


		


		
Y
		
Y
		
Y
		
Y
		


		
Y
		


		


		


		


		

		Author:
1. No of unit produced per hour
2. Scrap rate
		Y
		
7
		
5
		
2.69230769230769
	
	

		
Forcam
		
Forcam Force
		


		


		


		


		
Y
		
Y
		
Y
		
Y
		
Y
		
Y
		
Y
		


		


		


		

		Author:
1. Production Time
2. Cost
3. Yield
4. Scrap and Rework cost
5. Error reporting
		Y
		
8
		
7
		
4.30769230769231
	
	

		
Emerson Process Management
		
Syncade MES
		


		


		


		
Y
		


		


		


		
Y
		


		
Y
		
Y
		


		
Y
		


		


		
5
		
3
		
1.15384615384615
	
	

		
ABB
		
ABB MES
		
Y
		
Y
		
Y
		


		
Y
		
Y
		
Y
		
Y
		
Y
		
Y
		
Y
		


		
Y
		
Y
		
Y
		
13
		
7
		
7
	
	

		
Delfoi
		
Delfoi Planner
		
Y
		
Y
		
Y
		
Y
		


		
Y
		
Y
		
Y
		


		


		
Y
		


		
Y
		


		

		Author:
1. Lead times
2. Delivery accurcy
3. WIP
4. Machine utilization
		Y
		
10
		
4
		
3.07692307692308
	
	

		
Invensys
		
Wonderware MES
		
Y
		


		
Y
		
Y
		
Y
		


		
Y
		
Y
		


		
Y
		


		


		
Y
		


		
Y
		
9
		
4
		
2.76923076923077
	
	

		
MPDV Mikrolab 
		
HYDRA
		


		
Y
		


		
Y
		
Y
		
Y
		
Y
		
Y
		
Y
		
Y
		
Y
		
Y
		
Y
		
Y
		

		Author:
1. Time (Reference time, planned time, actual time)
2. Cost
3. Operation Analysis
4. Statistical Process Control
5. Consumed material 
6. Yield
7. Scrap
8. Machine Utilization rate
9. Robotoc Process Automation Analysis
		Y
		
13
		
8
		
8
	
	

		
Leanware
		
LEANWAREMES
		


		


		


		
Y
		


		


		
Y
		
Y
		


		


		
Y
		


		


		


		
Y
		
5
		
3
		
1.15384615384615
	
	

		
Epicor
		
Epicor Mattec MES
		


		
Y
		


		


		
Y
		
Y
		
Y
		
Y
		
Y
		


		
Y
		


		
Y
		


		


		
8
		
6
		
3.69230769230769
	
	

		
IQMS
		
IQMS MES
		


		
Y
		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		
Y
		
Y
		


		
Y
		


		
Y
		
5
		
2
		
0.769230769230769
	
	

		
GE
		
MEPMS
		
Y
		
Y
		


		
Y
		
Y
		


		
Y
		
Y
		
Y
		
Y
		


		


		
Y
		


		
Y
		
10
		
5
		
3.84615384615385
	
	

		
Aspen
		
aspenOne
		


		


		


		


		
Y
		


		
Y
		


		


		
Y
		
Y
		


		


		


		
Y
		
5
		
4
		
1.53846153846154
	
	

		
Dassault Systems
		
Apriso
		


		


		


		


		
Y
		
Y
		
Y
		
Y
		


		


		
Y
		


		


		


		
Y
		
6
		
5
		
2.30769230769231
	
	

		
Lighthouse
		
MES/MOM
		


		
Y
		


		
Y
		


		
Y
		
Y
		
Y
		
Y
		
Y
		
Y
		
Y
		
Y
		
Y
		
Y
		
12
		
7
		
6.46153846153846
	
	

		
Pyramid Solutions
		
intelliWORKS
		


		
Y
		


		
Y
		


		


		
Y
		
Y
		


		
Y
		
Y
		
Y
		
Y
		


		
Y
		
9
		
5
		
3.46153846153846
	
	

		
Aegis
		
FactoryLogix
		


		
Y
		
Y
		
Y
		
Y
		
Y
		


		


		


		
Y
		
Y
		


		
Y
		
Y
		
Y
		
10
		
4
		
3.07692307692308
	
	

		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


	
	

		

 
		
		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


	
	

		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


	
	

		


		


		


		


		


		


		
Performance Analysis (KPI reporting)
		


		


		


	
	

		


		


		


		


		


		


		
Time
		


		


		


	
	

		


		


		


		


		


		


		
Cost
		


		


		


	
	

		


		


		


		


		


		


		
Operation Analysis
		


		


		


	
	

		


		


		


		


		


		


		
Statistical Process Control
		


		


		


	
	

		


		


		


		


		


		


		
RPA Analysis
		


		


		


	
	

		


		


		


		


		


		


		
Yield
		


		


		


	
	

		


		


		


		


		


		


		
Scrap
		


		


		


	
	

		


		


		


		


		


		


		
OEE
		


		


		


	
	

		


		


		


		


		


		


		
TEEP (OEE X Utilization)
		


		


		


	
	

		


		


		


		


		


		


		
Utilization rate
		


		


		


	
	

		


		


		


		


		


		


		
Inventory consumption
		


		


		


	
	

		


		


		


		


		


		


		
Device History Record
		


		


		


	
	

		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


	
	

		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


	
	

		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


	
	

		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


	
	

		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


	
	

		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


	
	

		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


	
	

		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


	
	

		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


	
	

		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


	
	

		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


	



Sheet 2:  Open-source MES

	
	
	
	
	
	
	
	
	
	
	
	
	
	
	
	
	
	
	

		
Software
		
Functionalities
		


	
	

		


	
	

		
Vendor
		
MES Tool
		
Machine task allocation
		
Detailed Scheduling 
		
Dispatching Production Units 
		
Document Control
		
Tracking and Genealogy (Tracking and Traceability) 
		
Quality Management
		
Maintenance
		
Performance Analysis (KPI reporting)
		


	
	

		


		
Machine Data acquisition
		
People Productivity (labor tracking)
		
Product Tracking 
		
Material Tracking (Inventory, WIP, consumption) 
		
Energy consumption tracking
		
OEE and Downtime tracking
		
Process tracking
		
Tool Tracking
		


		
score
	
	

		
Odoo
		
Odoo
		


		
order receipt, 
		


		
data base maintaining BOM records
		


		
assign people to task
		
finished product notifications
		
Bill of materials tracking, delivery order tracking
		


		


		


		


		


		


		
cost
		
6
	
	

		
qcadoo
		
qcadoo
		


		
scheduling with gantt chart
		


		


		


		
labor work time
		
genealogy tree
		
Bill of materials, batch track record, warehouse components record
		


		


		


		


		


		


		
cost, calculated work time
		
5
	
	

		
MRPEasy 
		
MRPeasy
		


		
schedule and reschedule in gantt chart
		


		


		


		


		


		
Lot tracking, automated inventory transactions, stock tracking
		


		
Provides OEE calculations
		


		


		


		


		
provides a dashboard of orders, CRM, OEE  
		
4
	



Sheet 3: technical specs

	
	
	
	
	
	
	
	
	
	
	
	
	
	
	
	
	
	
	
	
	

		
Tools
		
	

		
SAP ME
		
SAP MII
		
AMPLA
		
SIMATIC IT
		
IBS:MES
		
Track & Trace 
		
Forcam Force
		
Syncade MES
		
ABB MES
		
Delfoi Planner
		
Wonderware MES
		
HYDRA
		
LEANWAREMES
		
Epicor Mattec MES
		
IQMS MES
		
MEPMS
		
aspenOne
		
Apriso
		
MES/MOM
		
intelliWORKS
		
FactoryLogix
	
	

		
Software requirements
		
	

		
Operaing System
		
	

		
Data requested
		
Data requested
		


		
Windows Server 2012 R2 StdE (full installation)
		


		


		


		


		
Data requested
		
Browser based 
		
Windows 10 Enterprise (x64, x86), Professional (x64, x86)
		
Windows Server 2016
		


		


		


		


		
Windows 10 Anniversary (2nd LTSB) Enterprise & Professional (64-bit)
		


		
Windows on premise support
		


		


	
	

		


		


		


		
Windows Server 2016 Standard (full installation)
		


		


		


		


		


		


		
Windows 8.1 Enterprise (x64, x86), Professional (x64, x86)
		
Windows Server 2012 R2
		


		


		


		


		
Windows 10 Enterprise & Professional (64-bit)
		


		


		


		


	
	

		


		


		


		
Windows 10 Home Version 1703
		


		


		


		


		


		


		
Windows Server 2012 Data Center, Embedded
		


		


		


		


		


		
Windows 8.1 Update 1 Enterprise & Professional (64-bit)
		


		


		


		


	
	

		


		


		


		
Windows 10 Professional Version 1703
		


		


		


		


		


		


		
Windows Server 2012 R2 Data Center, Embedded, Standard
		


		


		


		


		


		
Windows 7 Enterprise & Professional SP1 (64-bit)
		


		


		


		


	
	

		


		


		


		
Windows 10 Enterprise Version 1703
		


		


		


		


		


		


		
Windows Server 2016 Data Center, Standard
		


		


		


		


		


		
Windows Server 2016
		


		


		


		


	
	

		


		


		


		
Windows 7 Home Premium SP1
		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		
Windows Server 2012 R2
		


		


		


		


	
	

		


		


		


		
Windows 7 Professional SP1
		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		
Windows Server 2008 R2 SP1
		


		


		


		


	
	

		
MS Office support
		
	

		
Data requested
		
Data requested
		


		
Office 2016 (64-bit)
		


		


		


		


		
Data requested
		
NA
		


		


		


		


		


		


		
Office 2016 (64-bit)
		


		


		


		


	
	

		


		


		


		
Office 2016 (32-bit)
		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		
Office 2016 (32-bit)
		


		


		


		


	
	

		


		


		


		
Office 2013 SP1 (32-bit)
		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		
Office 2013 SP1 (32-bit)
		


		


		


		


	
	

		


		


		


		
Office 2010 SP2 (32-bit)
		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		
Office 2010 SP2 (32-bit)
		


		


		


		


	
	

		
Runtime support
		
	

		
Data requested
		
Data requested
		


		


		


		


		


		


		
Data requested
		
HTML based 
		


		


		


		


		


		


		
.NET Framework 4.6.2 
		


		


		


		


	
	

		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		
OA (Web service)-, XML- or direct database connection
		


		


		


		


		


		


		
32-bit Java 8 JRE update 91 
		


		


		


		


	
	

		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		
32-bit Java 8 JDK update 91 
		


		


		


		


	
	

		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		
64-bit Java 8 JRE update 91 
		


		


		


		


	
	

		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		
64-bit Java 8 JDK update 91 
		


		


		


		


	
	

		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		
MSXML 6 
		


		


		


		


	
	

		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		
Visual Studio 2010 Tools for Office Runtime
		


		


		


		


	
	

		
Browser support
		
	

		
Data requested
		
Data requested
		


		


		


		


		


		


		
Data requested
		
Internet Explorer 11 
		
Internet Explorer 12
		
Internet Explorer 13
		


		


		


		


		
NA
		


		
Internet Explorer 12
		


		


	
	

		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		
Google Chrome 
		
Google Chrome 
		
Google Chrome 
		


		


		


		


		


		


		
Google Chrome 
		


		


	
	

		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		
Safari on iOS
		
Safari on iOS
		
Safari on iOS
		


		


		


		


		


		


		
Safari on iOS
		


		


	
	

		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		
Firefox
		
Firefox
		
Firefox
		


		


		


		


		


		


		
Firefox
		


		


	
	

		
Cloud support
		
	

		
Data requested
		
Data requested
		


		


		


		


		


		


		
Data requested
		
Azure VM
		


		
provided
		


		


		


		


		
Azure VM
		


		
provided
		


		


	
	

		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		
Amazon VM
		


		


		


		


		


		


		
Amazon VM
		


		


		


		


	
	

		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		
Upcloud
		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


	
	

		
Time of tool integration
		
	

		
Data requested
		
Data requested
		


		


		


		


		


		


		
Data requested
		
Instant 
		
Instant 
		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		
Instant - cloud
		


		


	
	

		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		
variable - on premise
		


		


	
	

		
Virtualization 
		
	

		
Data requested
		
Data requested
		


		


		


		


		


		


		
Data requested
		
VMWare workstation virtualization
		
Microsoft Hyper-V  
		


		


		


		


		


		
Microsoft App-V 5.1 
		


		


		


		


	
	

		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		
VMWare virtualization 
		


		


		


		


		


		
Microsoft Hyper-V (Server) 
		


		


		


		


	
	

		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		
VMware ESX Server 6.0 (Server) 
		


		


		


		


	
	

		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		
Microsoft Terminal Services (Desktop) 
		


		


		


		


	
	

		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		
Citrix XenApp 7.9 (Desktop)
		


		


		


		


	
	

		
Hardware requirements
		
	

		
Desktop requirement
		
	

		
Data requested
		
Data requested
		


		
Processor Core i5-3320M, 3,3 GHz
		


		


		


		


		
Data requested
		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		
Computer and Processor: Intel Core-i5 family 2.8 gigahertz (GHz) or faster
		


		
Computer and Processor: Intel Core-i5 family 2.8 gigahertz (GHz) or faster
		


		


	
	

		


		


		


		
RAM 16 GB
		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		
Memory (RAM): 8 GB 1/2
		


		
Memory (RAM): 8 GB 1/2
		


		


	
	

		


		


		


		
HD SD with at least 50 GB of free space
		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		
Free Hard Disk Space: 80 GB 1
		


		


		


		


	
	

		


		


		


		
Screen resolution 1920 x1080 px
		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		
Display: Graphics card / monitor supports 1280 x 1024 or higher resolution
		


		


		


		


	
	

		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		
Network: 100 MB/second
		


		


		


		


	
	

		
Server requirement
		
	

		
Data requested
		
Data requested
		


		


		


		


		


		


		
Data requested
		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		
Computer and Processor: Quad Intel Wolfdale-DP family 2.66 gigahertz (GHz) (8 cores) or faster 2/3
		


		


		


		


	
	

		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		
Memory: 32 GB or more 2/3
		


		


		


		


	
	

		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		
Free Hard Disk Space: 500 GB 2/3
		


		


		


		


	
	

		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		
Display: Graphics card / monitor supports 1280 x 800 or higher resolution
		


		


		


		


	
	

		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		


		
Network: 100 MB/second or above, Gigabyte network recommended